Application Question
Medium difficulty • Concept in a practical situation
Question 1
Applied ConceptA student draws a Lewis structure for SO3 with a double bond to one oxygen and single bonds to two others. Another student argues that all S-O bonds should be equal. Who is correct, and how would you resolve this using resonance?
- The second student is correct in pointing out that experimentally, all three S-O bonds in SO3 are equivalent in length, which cannot be represented by a single Lewis structure showing one double bond and two single bonds.
- The concept of resonance resolves this: SO3 has three equivalent canonical forms, each with one S=O double bond and two S-O single bonds at different positions; the three forms are in equilibrium as a resonance hybrid.
- The resonance hybrid represents SO3 more accurately with all three S-O bonds having intermediate bond order (between 1 and 2), equal bond lengths, and equivalent character — consistent with experimental data.
- This is analogous to the CO3 2- ion and O3, where single Lewis structures are inadequate; resonance energy makes the hybrid more stable than any single canonical form.