Application Question
Hard difficulty • Concept in a practical situation
Question 1
Applied ConceptA chemist needs to separate Zr and Hf from a mixed ore. With reference to the properties of these elements and the concept of lanthanoid contraction, explain why this separation is extremely difficult.
- Zr (Z = 40) and Hf (Z = 72) have nearly identical atomic radii (Zr 160 pm, Hf 159 pm) and ionic radii because lanthanoid contraction in the 4f series compensates for the expected increase in size from 4d to 5d elements.
- Because their radii and electronic properties are so similar, Zr and Hf have almost identical crystal structures, ionisation enthalpies, electrode potentials and chemical reactivities — they co-occur naturally and form similar compounds.
- Conventional separation techniques based on differences in solubility, volatility or complex formation are largely ineffective; expensive fractional distillation of volatile chlorides or liquid-liquid extraction with specific complexing agents must be used.